MONROVIA, LIBERIA — Emmanuel K. Barnes, Assistant Minister for Manpower at the Ministry of Labour, has called for the resignation of Chief Justice Yamie Quiqui Gbeisay, citing concerns over judicial accountability, jury management, and the exercise of judicial authority.
In a strongly worded statement, Barnes argued that the Chief Justice should consider stepping down following remarks he interpreted as an acknowledgment that the jury management system under the judiciary’s supervision is vulnerable to bribery.
Barnes further alleged that the Chief Justice had publicly accused a citizen during a talk show and subsequently caused or directed judicial action resulting in the same individual’s imprisonment. He suggested that, if substantiated, such conduct would raise serious questions about judicial impartiality, due process, and the separation of personal allegations from the exercise of judicial authority.
He also criticized Gbeisay over his reported questioning of the President’s constitutional appointment powers, framing the matter as a concern about the constitutional boundaries governing relations among the branches of government.
According to Barnes, the cumulative effect of these controversies risks undermining public confidence in the judiciary and diminishing the institutional integrity of the Office of the Chief Justice.
Barnes called for legislative accountability, stating that, were he a member of the House of Representatives, he would introduce a resolution or pursue the appropriate constitutional process for the Chief Justice’s removal from office.
He also criticized the representation of Montserrado County District #14, arguing that the district’s lawmaker had failed to demonstrate sufficient engagement with issues requiring legislative oversight.
Legal and constitutional considerations
Any question of the Chief Justice’s removal must be addressed strictly in accordance with the Constitution of Liberia and applicable law. Allegations of misconduct, judicial impropriety, or vulnerability to bribery must be assessed against verifiable evidence and the procedures legally prescribed for investigation, accountability, and removal from office.
Barnes’ assertions represent his stated position. The underlying remarks, the circumstances of the alleged judicial action, and any relevant court records should be independently verified before the allegations are presented as established facts.
Barnes Calls for Chief Justice Gbeisay’s Resignation, Cites Concerns Over Judicial Accountability
